|
An Update on the Flight against Fusarium Head Blight at the University of Minnesota
University of Minnesota 2000 Scab Research Update The University of Minnesota Scab Research Initiative has been in place for about five years, getting underway in 1995 after Minnesota
lawmakers first appropriated funding to boost scab research in 1994, following the severe 1993 epidemic that affected much of the Northern Plains.
What has resulted since is an integrated, systematic focus on a specific research objective.
Thanks to the sustained funding commitment by the state of Minnesota, the U of M Scab Initiative has resulted in a number of structural and programmatic accomplishments over the past five years.
Structural accomplishments include a working coalition between small grain producers and the U of M, stronger linkages with crop scientists regionally and nationally to focus on scab research, and increased public awareness of the community-wide impacts of agricultural disasters.
The Initiative has resulted in better greenhouse and field research techniques, so that plant breeding material and pest management protocols can be tested no matter what the weather conditions.
The Initiative has also resulted in a more rapid and accurate means of measuring microtoxin levels in grain samples.
Programmatic accomplishments over the past five years include new wheat and barley varieties with improved scab tolerance, to be followed by even better varieties several years down the road. The Initiative has
also resulted in the discovery of sources and different types of scab resistance in exotic and domestic gene pools, and a better understanding of management techniques. This includes chemical and biological
control products and application techniques, as well as a better understanding of the impacts of tillage, previous crop, row spacing, companion crops, and other crop management approaches as a means of minimizing
the susceptibility of wheat and barley to scab.
Still, small grains producer and research leaders say that despite the considerable research progress, scab remains a threat to small grains production in Minnesota, and a sustained research effort is needed to
overcome the disease.
U of M Scab Initiative Accomplishments and Results Building a comprehensive research Initiative doesn't happen overnight. Research
objectives and priorities must be established. Qualified crop scientists need to be hired or assigned. Research equipment, facilities, and materials need to be put in place.
Methods of accomplishing research objectives must be determined. Quality control and multiple-year testing is needed to validate results.
That checklist has been accomplished under five years of sustained research by the U of M Scab Initiative. Basic knowledge of the fungal disease and methods of researching it have improved substantially.
More scab-tolerant wheat and barley varieties have been released as intermediate management tools, with better varieties on the way. New or more advanced research objectives and priorities are being established as initial ones are met. Some of the accomplishments of the U of M Scab Initiative over the past five years:
• Creation of scab screening nurseries in Crookston and Morris, and nursery improvements at St. Paul. • Establishment of a uniform regional scab nursery in MN, ND, SD, and
Manitoba. • Better understanding of scab-infected grain storability. • Better understanding of how scab affects grain quality and livestock.
• More knowledge on the efficacy, timing and application of fungicides. • Better understanding of how scab is affected by tillage, field residue, row
spacing, companion and rotational crops, and other crop management approaches as a means of minimizing the disease. • Better understanding of how scab inoculum develops and spreads.
• Development of techniques that induce uniform infections by scab in research plots and greenhouse tests that result in better screening of wheat and barley lines.
• Application of scab-resistant materials in exotic and domestic germplasm. • Release of four wheat lines (Bacup, Verde, HJ98, McVey) and a barley line (MNbrite) with improved scab tolerance.
• Utilization of molecular approaches to accelerate resistance. • Development of a rapid and accurate means of mycotoxin analysis in scabby grain samples, and computerized optical scanning approaches.
• Better communication and coordination on scab research among crop scientists, producers, lawmakers, and others, state and nationally.
Development of scab-tolerant barley varieties: Searching For Increased Resistance, Zero to Low DON
Don Rasmusson (left) and Kevin Smith, barley breeders at the University of Minnesota, have evaluated seven new sources of resistance in barley
that are parents of populations that will be grown in scab nurseries this summer. They have expanded their greenhouse screening efforts and have evaluated five first-cycle
breeding populations in replicated field trials. These populations are derived from crosses between a new source of resistance to the program and an eliteMinnesota breeding line.
Rasmusson and Smith have also evaluated 7 second or third cycle breeding populations that involve crosses between a selected scab-resistant progeny
from a first or second cycle breeding population and an elite Minnesota breeding line. Progeny from these crosses are more likely to produce an
acceptable variety. They have also evaluated 21 lines from advanced cycles of scab resistance breeding in yield trials last summer to assess their
agronomic and malting quality properties, with evaluation of the advanced material to continue.
"We're still searching for something that has an increased level of resistance, and that gets the DON level to an acceptable level," says Rasmusson. The malting and brewing industry prefers malting barley with
DON levels at less than 2 parts per million.
In the last year, a new technician has joined the U of M barley breeding program to evaluate and use DNA marker technology to enhance the program's effort to improve scab resistance.
Development of scab-tolerant wheat varieties: Molecular Markers May Help Breeding Effort
In the average hard red spring wheat plant, there are over 50,000 genes that control genetic responses from how and when the plant grows to its
ability to fight pests. A key objective for U of M wheat breeder Jim Anderson is to develop scab-tolerant spring wheat varieties that also have
good yield and quality characteristics, and that do not compromise other agronomic traits and tolerance to other pests.
Crossbreeding wheat lines to achieve that mix of traits desirable in a new variety is difficult enough, let alone identify genes in the lines that make a
cross worthwhile. It's a tall order—like searching for a needle in a haystack.
Anderson's breeding program is using DNA markers to help identify genes in wheat responsible for scab tolerance. Just in the last year, Anderson's
program identified an additional marker that helps explain how varieties differ in their degree of scab tolerance.
Molecular markers are an accurate means of "fingerprinting" germplasm, enabling Anderson to follow traits or genetic makeup in the course of his
wheat breeding efforts. Then, based on the pattern revealed by these markers, crosses are selected for better scab tolerance.
Anderson's wheat breeding program has 142 lines in advanced yield trials and approximately 450 lines in preliminary yield trials that have been screened in inoculated, misted scab screening nurseries.
Bob Busch (left), who has been a USDA-ARS wheat geneticist and U of M wheat breeder
since 1978, will retire in June 2000. Jim Anderson assumed the reins of the U of M's wheat breeding program last summer.
FHB Resistance in Wheat and Barley: Effective Screening Nurseries Scab Nurseries Single Out Superior Wheat, Barley Lines
Although production management strategies such as staggered planting dates, crop rotation, and foliar fungicides all play a role in minimizing scab,
the best method of controlling the fungal disease in wheat and barley will likely be more tolerant varieties. U of M crop scientists screen or test
wheat and barley lines for scab tolerance in greenhouse and field "scab nurseries."
New varieties and potential releases of both wheat and barley are screened for their level of resistance to scab at the Northern Scab Nursery, under the direction of John Wiersma at the Northwest Research and Outreach Center, Crookston, MN. Advanced lines from breeding programs in
the Dakotas, Minnesota, and Manitoba are evaluated each year in this nursery. Most of the lines are being evaluated in other FHB nurseries as well, to gauge scab tolerance in different
geographic areas. Decisions regarding release of new varieties are made after reviewing results from several nurseries and years.
The U of M's field screening efforts have expanded the last few years: For example, in 1999 about 800 to 900 barley lines were evaluated in field nurseries at Crookston, the West
Central Research and Outreach Center in Morris, and at the Experiment Station in St. Paul. This year, close to 2000 barley lines will be screened.
Screening wheat and barley lines for scab tolerance can be challenging, since multiple environments (test locations, years, disease severities) are
needed to confirm that truly superior genotypes have been identified. Still, U of M crop scientists have improved screening methods to a point where
they are much more confident in the test results. U of M plant pathologist, Ruth Dill-Macky, leads the overall screening efforts.
Different levels of disease pressure are created using various amounts of infected corn seed inoculum and a controlled misting system. If varieties are
grown under a wide range of disease conditions, the more favorable varieties will exhibit resistance to scab across that range.
Residue Management and Inoculum Potential of Fusarium Residue-Burning Study To Begin This Year
U of M Soil Scientist Albert Sims, plant pathologist Ruth Dill-Macky, and other crop scientists at the U of M are studying how scab inoculum
survives on plant residue, particularly straw and small grains head tissues.
The residue composition study, which began in October, 1997, clearly shows that Fusarium can survive on plant residue until flowering of a small
grain crop the next year. Researchers continue to evaluate results of the study to make more advanced conclusions.
Also in the works: A study on how burning of residue from small grains crops may affect the survival and inoculum production capacity of scab.
The study, to be conducted on large plots situated in commercial fields in the Red River Valley, will get underway this year.
Biology, Epidemiology, and Management of Scab Greenhouse Screening, Scab Testing Advancements
Biology and epidemiology studies search for answers on what increases or decreases the potential for scab development, mechanisms of plant resistance, and how environment affects disease development.
Included in the research on management strategies is an evaluation of fungicide performance over multiple locations and states. The fungicide
evaluation at the U of M is coordinated by Extension Plant Pathologist Roger Jones.
Over the last several years, plant pathologists Ruth Dill-Macky, Kent Evans, Charles Hu, and others at the Uof M have improved the University's ability to generate inoculum of the scab fungus Fusarium graminearum for use in greenhouse and field testing, and to inoculate
plants uniformly. They have been able to increase the volume of wheat and barley lines being screened (from about 1,000 to 6,000), and made progress in screening material that combines desirable resistance and
agronomic traits.
Greenhouse testing of wheat and barley lines is conducted three times annually at the U of M: Spring, summer, and winter. From 1994 to 1999,
about 10,000 wheat genotypes (70,000 plants) including 100 Chinese wheat varieties have been inoculated and evaluated in the greenhouse at St. Paul.
About the U of M Scab Research Initiative Over the past five years, the state of Minnesota has earmarked close to $5
million for scab research at the University of Minnesota (1994- $477,000; 1996/97- $1 million; 1998/99- $1.65 million; 2000/01 $1.65 million). Additionally, Minnesota producers have invested well over $1 million
through the wheat and barley checkoff programs administered by the Minnesota Wheat and Barley Councils for disease research.
This research partnership has resulted in what may be the largest and most comprehensive effort among agricultural experiment stations in the nation. The U of M Scab Research Initiative involves about 20 principle
investigators and in all, about 75 people in four departments and three campuses (St. Paul, Crookston, Morris).
Molecular Approaches of Genetic Resistance to FHB in Wheat and Barley Biotech Side of Scab Research Has Multi-Faceted Goals
There are four facets to the U of M's molecular research program focusing on identifying genes and transgenic mechanisms by which scab resistance can be developed in wheat and barley:
1) Mapping scab resistance genes in barley—Mapping involves using molecular markers to identify regions of the barley genome that confer with
scab resistance. Molecular markers are used to indicate the location of the genomic regions that carry scab resistance genes. Ultimately, the mapping
will enable moving genomic regions of barley lines containing scab resistance genes to other barley germplasm adapted for production in Minnesota.
2) Defensive plant response—This work identifies genes in wheat that are involved in the plant's defense response, and specific tissues in the
wheat head where infection occurs. U of M molecular scientists are comparing the response to Fusarium graminear-um in the resistant Chinese wheat called Sumai3, compared to the Wheaton variety, which is
susceptible to scab. This information will help the researchers determine what types of genes are involved in resistance, or are turned on at a higher
level or sooner than others. A better understanding of the infection process and what the plant does to combat infection may make it easier to develop scab-tolerant wheat plants.
3) Gene discovery—This objective is to identify antifungal genes from wheat, barley or any other organism, and isolate genes involved with degrading or detoxifying deoxynivalenol (DON).
4) Transformation—Antifungal protein genes that have been identified from previous studies and from the gene discovery aspect of the U of M's
molecular research program are inserted into wheat and barley lines. The U of M has successfully developed transgenic wheat and barley plants,
which carry antifungal protein genes that degrade cell walls and membranes of Fusarium. U of M researchers are now testing these transgenic plants
to confirm that they will confer an enhanced level of resistance to scab, as intended.
Confirming transformation success can be expensive and timely, with a cost estimated at over $75,000 and a process that can take at least 16 months.
Thus, one objective of the Minnesota Scab Initiative is to develop a rapid "pre-test" of antifungal genes in engineering better scab tolerance in wheat
and barley lines. U of M plant pathologist Richard Zeyen is the leader of a project designed to directly determine the efficacy of antifungal genes in
preventing or retarding the growth of scab, subsequently streamlining the transformation process.
Molecular geneticist Gary Muehlbauer oversees transgenic efforts at the U of M to identify and
insert genes in wheat and barley that convey increased levels of resistance to scab and Don.
Mycotoxin Detection and Analysis Lab Strives For Fast, Accurate DON Sampling
The mycotoxin laboratory in the U of M's Department of Plant Pathology provides quick and reliable mycotoxin analysis to all research laboratories involved in the U of M scab research project.
Dr. Weiping Xie, lab leader, says accuracy and speed are two key factors in mycotoxin analysis, which is deoxynivalenol (DON, or vomitoxin) in
wheat and barley samples. Xie's lab has been able to increase the number of samples it evaluates from about 30 samples a day a few years ago to about 100 today. The lab collaborates with about a dozen other
laboratories in the Midwest to cross-check sampling accuracy.
Coordination and Outreach Pfleger Named MN Scab Initiative Coordinator
Frank Pfleger, professor and head of the U of M
Department of Plant Pathology, serves as coordinator of the Minnesota Scab Initiative. He replaced Gary Lemme, former head of the West Central Research and Outreach Center in Morris, who accepted a position
with the Michigan Agricultural Experiment Station last fall.
Pfleger serves as University liaison, working with Initiative researchers and leaders of the Minnesota Wheat and Barley Councils to keep research programs moving forward and to plan and disseminate scab research
information to Initiative researchers as well as the public.
Small Grains Specialist Jochum Wiersma (no relation to NROC crop scientist John Wiersma) plays a key role in the effort to educate pro ducers about Minnesota Scab Initiative research results. Based at the NROC since 1995, Wiersma works with county extension educators to develop educational programs as
well as address timely small grains-related production issues. He also conducts research and on-farm trials as demonstration and evaluation tools in western Minnesota.
Federal Research at CDL Complements State Effort "One of the things we want to do is to foster more collaborative efforts
with the research we're doing here at the U of M, and scab research that's underway nationally," says Frank Pfleger, coordinator of the Minnesota Scab Initiative.
To that end, the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Cereal Disease Lab located at the U of M's St. Paul campus complements scab research conducted under the Minnesota Scab Initiative. The CDL still focuses
much of its attention on rust research, including the monitoring of rust infections in small grains across the nation.
However, about one-third of the CDL's research efforts now are focused on scab. Including research by Bill Bushnell, conducted cooperatively with Ron Skadsen, USDA-ARS Barley and Malt Lab, Madison, Wis. Their
research has resulted in a method that greatly improves the ability to trace development of the scab fungus in infected head tissues, and ultimately, will
help determine the principal pathways of infection in head tissues of wheat and barley.
Corby Kistler, CDL research geneticist, is studying genetic variations of the scab pathogen nationwide, which will lead to a better understanding of how Fusarium may infect a wheat field in Minnesota as opposed to a wheat
field in Michigan or Arkansas, for example. Kistler also plans to include scab sampling as a new component to the national rust survey conducted annually by the CDL.
In all, about four crop scientists at the CDL devote at least a portion of their research to scab, according to Kurt Leonard, who heads the CDL. An additional researcher will join the CDL this year to further boost
research efforts there. More information about CDL research may be found on the web: www.cdl.umn.edu
Scabby Wheat Assessment Using Machine Vision and Neural Networks Computer Optically Scans Scabby Kernels Determining the incidence of scab in grain samples has always been done
by human visual observation, which can mean variable, subjective results. Creating a more accurate machine-based measurement is an ongoing project of the Minnesota Scab Initiative.
Roger Ruan and other researchers at the U of M Department of Biosystems and Ag Engineering
are developing a machine that will replace human eyes to determine the level of visual scabby kernels in wheat.
A useable system has been developed, but the machine-method of estimating scab damage is being refined to evaluate most varieties. The technology may also have
applications in identity-preserved grain sampling for end-use markets.
Fusarium Head Blight (Scab) Research Initiative Breakdown of Major Projects, Funding, Principle Contacts
Development Of Disease-Resistant Wheat Varieties Budget: $199,000 Contacts: Jim Anderson, ph. 612-625-9763, email: ander319@tc.umn.edu
Bob Busch, wheat breeder, ph. 612-625-1975, email: busch005@maroon. tc.umn.edu
Development of Disease-Resistant Barley Varieties Budget: $140,000 Contacts: Don Rasmusson, ph. 612-625-7278, email: rasmu002@maroon. tc.umn.edu
Kevin Smith, ph. 612-624-1211, email: Smith376@ tc.umn.edu
Molecular Approaches of Genetic Resistance to FHB in Wheat and Barley Budget: $180,000 Contact: Gary Muehlbauer, ph. 612-625-6228, email: gary.j.muehlbauer-1 @maroon.tc.umn.edu
Biology, Epidemiology, and Management of Scab Budget: $275,000 Contact: Ruth Dill-Macky, ph. 612-625-2227, email: ruthdm@puccini.crl. umn.edu
Mycotoxin Detection and Analysis Budget: $122,000 Contact: Weiping Xie, ph. 612-625-2751, email: weipingx@puccini.crl. umn.edu
FHB Resistance in Spring Wheat and Barley: Effective Screening Nurseries Budget: $100,000 Contact: John Wiersma, ph. 218-281-8607, email: jwiersma@mail.crk. umn.edu
Residue Management and Inoculum Potential of Fusarium Budget: $109,000 Contact: Albert Sims, ph. 218-281-8619, email: asims@mail.crk.umn.edu
Support Small Grains Plant Pathologist Positions, Crookston Budget: $85,000 Contact: Larry Smith ph. 218-281-8602, e-mail: lsmith@mail.crk.umn.edu
Investigate Pathways of Head Invasions by F. Graminearum Budget: $40,000. Contact: William Bushnell Ph.651-625-7781, email: billb@puccini.crl.umn.edu
Pretesting of Antifungal Genes for Use in Genetic Engineering of Wheat and Barley Budget: $80,000 Contact: Richard Zeney ph. 612-625-4754, email: richz@puccini.crl.umn.edu
Scab Research at West Central Research and Outreach Center, Morris Budget: $53,000 Contacts: Ruth Dill-Macky, ph. 320-589-1711
Scabby Wheat Assessment Using Machine Vision and Neural Networks Budget: $40,000 Contact: Roger Ruan, ph. 612-625-1710, email: rruan@rabbit.bae. umn.edu\
Coordination and Communication Budget: $146,000
Contact: Frank Pfleger, ph. 612-625-9736; email: francisp@puccini.crl. umn.edu
TOTAL: $1.65 million
For more complete research project information or budget details, contact FHB Coordinator Frank Pfleger, ph. 612-625-9736; email: francisp
@puccini.crl. umn.edu
Other Contacts:
Kurt Leonard, USDA Cereal Disease Lab, ph. 612-625-5786, email: kurtl@ puccini.crl.umn.edu
Jochum Wiersma, U of M Small Grains Specialist, ph. 218-281-8629, email: wiers002@maroon.tc.umn.edu
Phil Larsen, Vice President & Dean COAFES, ph. 612-625-1999, email: phill@puccini.crl.umn.edu
Tom Anderson, Chair, Small Grain Research and Education Committee, ph. 218-354-7556, email: farmandy1@aol.com
Marvin Zutz, Executive Director, Minnesota Barley Research and Promotion Council, ph. 218-253-4311, email: mzutz@gvtel.com
David Torgerson, Executive Director, Minnesota Wheat Research and Promotion Council, ph. 218-253-4311, email: torgerso@gvtel.com
For More Information....
More comprehensive scab research information may be found in the booklet, "1999 Wheat Research Review." It is free to the public and may be requested by contacting the Minnesota Wheat Research and Promotion
Council, 1-800-242-6118. More scab research information is also available on the World Wide Web, at the MWRPC web site, www.smallgrains.org, and the University of Minnesota Agricultural
Experiment Station, www.maes.umn.edu. Research conducted at the U of M and other research institutions under the U.S. Wheat and Barley Scab Initiative can be found on the Internet at: www.scabusa.org.
This report prepared cooperatively by the University of Minnesota and the Minnesota Wheat Research and Promotion Council.
|