Issue 70
Prairie Grains

Library

Home

E-Mail

Back

Prairie Grains is the official publication of the Minnesota Association of Wheat Growers, North Dakota Grain Growers Association, Montana Grain Growers Association and South Dakota Wheat, Inc.

Copyright Prairie Grains Magazine
June 2005

Insect Management

Herbicide-Insecticide Combinations
Efficacy data on herbicide-insecticide mixtures are limited because of the number of potential combinations, but some combinations have been shown to increase crop injury compared to either pesticide applied alone. Following is information based on label restrictions and/or research indicating crop injury or decreased control with some product combinations.

2,4-D: Wheat injury but not lower wheat yield with 2,4-D amine combined with Lorsban. 2,4-D, dicamba, bromoxynil+MCPA or Curtail mixed with Asana, Cygon, Di-Syston, Warrior, or Lorsban caused no wheat injury in University of Wyoming studies.

Assert: Use caution when tank-mixing organophosphate insecticides for use on barley and sunflower. Assert and Di-Syston caused barley injury in University of Wyoming research.

Dicamba: Oil-based insecticides increase risk of wheat injury.

Basagran: Basagran should not be tank-mixed with Scout or any organophosphate insecticide as crop injury may result.

Betamix/Betanex: Increased sugar beet injury occurred from tank-mixtures with Lorsban, malathion, or Sevin XLR. Oil-based additives increase risk of sugar beet injury.Bromoxynil: Refer to label for directions on the order of adding products to the spray tank and for the complete list of insecticides that can be tank-mixed with bromoxynil.

Assure II, Fusilade DX, Fusion, Poast, Prism, Select: Reduced grass control may result from tank-mixes of Fusilade DX with Lorsban, malathion, Sevin XLR, or Pydrin, or Poast mixed with Sevin XLR Plus or Pydrin. No decrease in grass control resulted from Poast tank-mixed with Lorsban or malathion.

Glyphosate: No antagonism or injury to resistant crops occurred when applied in combination with Warrior, Asana, Sevin, and Capture insecticides.

Sulfonylurea Herbicides (SU): Severe crop injury may result from tank-mixing SU herbicides with organophosphate insecticides. Most SU labels do not allow addition of Lorsban or malathion. SU herbicides and insecticides should be tank-mixed only when experience or research indicated crop safety.

Refer to product label for directions on the order of adding products to the spray tank and for the complete list of insecticides that can be tank-mixed.

Compatibility Test for Pesticide Mixture
Under federal law, combining pesticides is legal unless the pesticide labeling of any of the pesticides involved instructs you not to combine them. However, not all pesticides work well when mixed together. They must be compatible — that is, mixing them together must not reduce their safety or effectiveness. The more pesticides you mix together, the greater the chance of undesirable effects. 

A way to test for tank-mix compatability:

Get a large, clean, clear glass container, such as a quart jar. Use the same water (or other diluent) that you will use when making up the larger mixture. Add the water and each of the products in the same proportions as you will mix them. For example, each quart of pesticide that you add to 50 gallons of final spray mixture is the equivalent of about 1 teaspoon per quart of water. Unless the pesticide labeling states otherwise, add pesticides to the diluent using the “W-A-L-E” plan:

  • Add some of the diluent first
  • Add Wettable and other powders and water-dispersible granules
  • Agitate thoroughly and add the remaining diluent
  • Add the Liquid products, such as solutions, surfactants, and flowables
  • Add Emulsifiable concentrates last
  • Shake the jar vigorously. Feel the sides of the jar to determine if the mixture is giving off heat. If so, the mixture may be undergoing a chemical reaction and the pesticides should not be combined. Let the mixture stand for about 15 minutes and feel again for unusual heat.
  • If scum forms on the surface, if the mixture clumps, or if any solids settle to the bottom (except for wettable powders), the mixture probably is not compatible. Finally, if no signs of incompatibility appear, test the mixture on a small area of the surface where it is to be applied.

    Resolving Incompatibility
    Add 6 drops of compatibility agent and stir well. If mixture appears compatible, allow it to stand for 1 hour, stir well, and check it again. If the mixture appears incompatible, repeat one or two more times, using 6 drops of compatibility agent each time.

    If incompatibility still persists, dispose of this mixture, clean the jar, and repeat the above steps, but add 6 drops of compatibility agent to the water before anything else is added.

    If the mixture is still incompatible, do not mix the chemicals in the spray tank.

    To overcome this problem you might consider the following alternatives:

    a) Use a different water supply. Hard water can contribute to incompatibility
    b) Change brands or formulations of chemicals.
    c) Change the order of mixing.

    Make only one change at a time, and perform a complete test, as described above, before making another change. Do not mix the chemicals in the spray tank if incompatibility cannot be resolved.

    The Effect of Water pH on Insecticides
    Alkaline water (containing soluble mineral salts – alkaline waters are considered to be hard water) used in spray mixtures can seriously reduce the effectiveness of some insecticides, particularly if the mixture is left standing in the spray tank for an extended period of time. Insecticides classified as organophosphates and carbamates break down easily in high pH water. Use water of pH 7.00 or less with these insecticides. The pH of any solution will be between zero and 14, with anything below seven being alkaline. To compare, lemon juice is acidic with a pH of two. Milk of Magnesia is alkaline with a pH of 10.5, and distilled water is neutral with a pH of seven. If water having a pH of 7.0 or less is not available, use a buffering agent to alter the water pH. Buffering agents can be purchased from agricultural chemical dealers. Water pH testing kits can be bought from some ag dealers.

    Stem Maggot May Cause White Heads in Wheat
    White heads caused by wheat stem maggot feeding can often be observed in wheat fields. Typically, only 1 to 5% of the heads are affected, and they appear to occur scattered at random through the field.

    With wheat stem maggot damage, the head and the stem down to the top node are dead, with the rest of the plant green. The head will pull out with a gentle tug, and usually there is evidence of insect chewing on the stem above the top node where it broke when pulled. Single heads are affected rather than the whole plant. These symptoms can be differentiated from white heads caused by common root rot. With root rot, typically the whole plant is whitened and the whole plant easily pulls from the soil, with browned or blacked roots, as well. No chemical controls are available for wheat stem maggot.

    Managing Grasshoppers
    Peak hatch in the Northern Plains usually occurs about mid-June, and usually nears completion by late June. Cool and extremely dry springs may delay the hatch, allowing it to continue into July. Dry conditions increase the risk of grasshopper infestations.

    Whenever grasshopper populations reach the threatening level, feeding damage to crops should be anticipated. Directing control efforts at nymphs in hatching sites is recommended to minimize the total area requiring insecticide treatment, and permits lower insecticide rates for effective control.

    Grasshopper Thresholds/Infestation Ratings

     

    Nymphs (Young hoppers)
    per square yard

    Adults
    per square yard

    Rating

    Margin

    Field

    Margin

    Field

    Light

    25 - 35

    15-23

    10 - 20

    3 - 7

    Threatening

    50 - 75

    30-45

    21 - 40

    8 - 14

    Severe

    100 - 150

    60 - 90

    41 - 80

    15 - 28

    Very Severe

    200+

    120

    80+

    28+

    Grasshopper management information and color survey maps can be found online at http://fs-sdy2.sidney.ars.usda.gov/grasshopper. Updated N.D. IPM grasshopper surveys can be found online during the growing season at www.ag.ndsu.nodak.edu/aginfo/ndipm.

    Orange Blossom Wheat Midge
    Orange wheat blossom midge problems in Northern Plains wheat have been low the past few years. Weather conditions during the spring and summer are very important in determining if economic injury will occur. If heading coincides with emergence of the midge and weather conditions are favorable for the female to lay eggs, producers will need to monitor fields, even in areas where the survey says populations are low, to determine if treatment is necessary. High soil moisture, warm and calm conditions, and high humidity have favored midge egg laying in past years.

    ORANGE BLOSSOM WHEAT MIDGE02

    Wheat is susceptible to midge infestation from the time the head emerges from the boot until 80% of the primary heads have anthers visible. Treatments are warranted when 1 or more midge are observed for every 4 or 5 heads of spring wheat, and when 1 or more midge are observed for every 7 or 8 heads of durum. Treatments after 50% of the first heads have flowered are not recommended due to reduced levels of efficacy and for the protection of a parasitic wasp that attacks the midge eggs.

    More information online: www.ag.ndsu.nodak.edu/aginfo/entomology/
    entupdates/Wheat_Midge/owbm.htm

    Hessian Fly
    The Hessian fly overwinters as a maggot or pupa in winter wheat, volunteer grain, and wheat stubble. Overwintered maggots pupate and emerge as adults from April to May, infesting winter and spring planted wheat. By June, maggots pupate, emerging as adults in August to lay eggs for the overwintering generation. Thimet and Cruiser are registered as a planting time and a seed treatment for wheat, respectively, but populations of this pest rarely warrant the need for such treatments in North Dakota. Burying stubble and destroying volunteer grain after the first killing frost or early in the spring before fly emergence helps suppress adult populations.

    HESSIAN FLY02

    Aphids
    Greenbug, bird cherry oat, and English grain are common types of aphids in the Northern Plains. Treatment threshold is 85% stems with at least one aphid present, prior to complete heading. The greatest risk of yield loss from aphids feeding on wheat is in the vegetative-to-boot stages. Field scouting should begin at stem elongation and continue up to the heading stage of wheat. Aphid populations, at or above the thresholds, during these growth stages will result in economic injury to plants. The Russian Wheat Aphid can occasionally be found, but not at economic damage levels. No RWA have been reported in North Dakota since the early 90s.

    APHIDS02

    Soybean aphid
    Begin scouting fields at V3-V4. No treatment recommended at this time and is discouraged, so insecticides do not reduce the presence of predators and parasites of aphids. The critical growth stage for making most soybean aphid treatment decisions appears to be the late vegetative to early reproductive stages (Vn-R3). Assessing aphid populations at this time is critical. Conclusions from 2001-2003 management programs found that the best results from an aphid treatment occurred from mid-July to early August. Treatment to manage soybean aphid would be recommended at growth stages R1-R4, when aphids are abundant on most plants. Treatment guideline: When aphids number 25 or more per sampled leaflet or 250 total aphids per plant.

    Soybean aphids have tended to initially colonize fields near shelterbelts, southern field edges, or perhaps some other protective structure. Particular attention should be given to smaller fields (less than 30 acres) that are surrounded by wooded areas. Check field edges first to detect the earliest colonization. Surveys have indicated that it takes about 3 to 4 weeks for aphids to be detected in other areas of the field. Eventually, the larger colonies develop where initial colonization occurs.

    Another method of sampling developed at the University of Minnesota is a binomial sequential sampling plan or “speed scouting” recommended for use through the pod fill stage.  If a plant has less than 40 aphids, consider it non-infested; however if the plant has 40 or more aphids (counting additional aphids is not necessary after 40), consider the plant infested. Based on the speed scouting sampling plan, three treatment decisions are possible: 1. Do not treat the field; 2. Treat the field; or 3. Resample the field in 3-4 days.  More information about the speed sampling method on the Internet: www.soybeans.umn .edu/crop/insects/aphid/aphid_sampling.htm .

    An NDSU Bulletin on managing soybean aphids, revised in 2004, can be found online at www.ext.nodak.edu/extpubs/plantsci/rowcrops/e1232w.htm .

    Corn borer
    Managing corn borer is a challenge due to the lengthy emergence interval of the moths from overwintering. In N.D., borers have the potential for one or two generations during the season. The two generation borers are present in the southern region of the state. They begin emerging in early June and represent the first flush of larval feeding. The single generation borer is present throughout N.D., emerging from mid-June to August.

    The challenge is to distinguish when egg laying and larval populations can be tolerated or if they need to be controlled. Corn should be monitored weekly for at least five weeks once plants exceed an extended leaf height of 17 inches. At this point, corn borer larvae will be able to survive on the plant. Inspect plants for the presence of egg masses, whorl feeding, and active larvae.

    CORN BORER LARVAE02

    Observing moth activity around field margins or within the field may alert you to developing infestations. Recent corn borer infestations in N.D. developed in mid- to late-July and August as a result of the late emergence of the numerous single generation type borers. In other years, the two generation borers emerging first may contribute more to significant infestations.

    Field scouting worksheets and economic threshold guidelines can be found in the 2005 N.D. Field Crop Insect Management Guide, online at www.ext.nodak.edu/extpubs/plantsci/pests/e1143w1.htm.

    Cool Grain to Prevent Storage Problems

    cool03

    Grain should be cooled to 20-25°F for winter storage. If desired, the grain can be warmed to 35-40°F in March for storage into the summer. The goal should be to keep the grain cool to enhance its storability. Keeping the grain cool will reduce the potential for insect infestation and grain spoilage.

    -----------------

    Insect Info on the Internet

    2005 N.D. Field Crop Insect Management Guide
    www.ext.nodak.edu/extpubs/plantsci/pests/e1143w1.htm

    Insect Updates for N.D.
    www.ag.ndsu.nodak.edu/aginfo/entomology/entupdates/index.htm

    NDSU Crop Insect Publications
    www.ext.nodak.edu/extpubs/bugcrops.htm

    SDSU Extension Entomology
    http://plantsci.sdstate.edu/ent/

    U of M Soybean Aphid Information Page
    www.soybeans.umn.edu/crop/insects/aphid/aphid.htm

    Regional IPM Bugweb Insect Monitoring Network
    www.mnipm.umn.edu/BugWeb