Issue 62
Prairie Grains

Library

Home

E-Mail

Back

Prairie Grains is the official publication of the Minnesota Association of Wheat Growers, North Dakota Grain Growers Association, Montana Grain Growers Association and South Dakota Wheat, Inc.

Copyright Prairie Grains Magazine
June 2004

Winter Wheat

N.D. Hard Red Winter Wheat Variety Selection Guide
Hard red winter wheat varieties adapted for production in North Dakota are described in the following tables.  Successful winter wheat production depends on numerous factors including selecting the right variety for a particular area.

Recommended seeding dates for winter wheat are Sept. 10 to Sept. 30 south of N.D. Hwy 200 and Sept. 1 to Sept. 15 in northern regions. Planting after the recommended dates reduces winter survival and grain yields. Planting prior to the recommended date unnecessarily depletes soil moisture reserves, increases risk of disease and may reduce winter survival.

Winter wheat should be seeded at a rate of 1 million viable seeds per acre or about 80 lbs/ac. Higher seeding rates are suggested for late seeding or for poor seedbed conditions.  Only the most winter-hardy varieties available should be considered when growing winter wheat in North Dakota. Of the current varieties, Roughrider, Agassiz, Seward, Elkhorn, Ransom, Crimson, Harding, and Jerry possess the best combination of winter-hardiness and yield.  When wheat streak mosaic virus is a concern, Crimson or Harding should be grown; of the varieties adapted to N.D., they have the best tolerance.

Phosphorus aids overwinter survival by stimulating root growth and fall tillering. The secondary root system that develops with tillering is essential for a healthy deep-rooted plant capable of withstanding stress. If winter wheat is planted on bare soil, an application of phosphorus is essential. While important, the contribution of phosphorus to overwinter survival is secondary to varietal hardiness.

When selecting a top yielding variety, it is best to use data that summarizes several years and locations. Choose the variety that on average performs the best at multiple locations near you over several years.

Compiled by NDSU extension agronomist Joel Ransom, with the following contributing data to this report: Blaine Schatz and Steve Zwinger – Carrington; Bryan Hansen – Langdon; Pat Carr and Glenn Martin – Dickinson; Scott Meyer – Fargo; Eric Eriksmoen – Hettinger; Mark Halvorson – Minot; Neil Riveland – Williston

NSDU Table 1. 2003 Hard Red Winter Wheat Variety Descriptions

Variety

Agent or Origin

Release year

Quality

Leaf

Rust2

Stem

Rust2

Mat

urity

Straw

Strength

Height

Winter1

Hardiness

AC Readymade

Can.

1996

NA

S

S

med.

strong

med.

good

Agassiz

ND

1983

Average

S

R

med.

med.

med.

good

Alliance

NE

1997

NA

S

NA

early

strong

short

good

Arapahoe

NE

1989

Poor

MS

MR

med.

med.

med.

fair

CDC Kestrel

Can.

1994

Poor

S

S

med.

m. strong

med.

good

CDC Raptor

Can.

2002

NA

NA

NA

med.

m. strong

m. short

good

CDC Falcon

Can/WPB

2000

NA

NA

NA

med.

m. strong

short

good

Crimson

SD

1997

NA

MS

NA

med.

m. strong

med.

fair-good

Culver

ND

1999

NA

NA

NA

m. early

m. strong

med.

good

Elkhorn

ND

1995

Average

MR

R5

med.

med.

med.

good

Erhardt

MT

1996

NA6

S

R

med.

strong

med.

good

Expedition

SD

2002

Average

MS

R

med.

strong

med.

good

Harding

SD

1999

NA

MS/MR

NA

med.

m. strong

med.

good

Jagalene

Agripro

2001

NA

NA

NA

early

strong

short

fair-poor

Jerry

ND

2001

Good

MR

R

med.

strong

med.

good

McClintock

Can

2003

NS

NA

NA

med.

strong

med.

fair-good

McGuire

MT

1996

NA

S

R

m. early

strong

m. tall

fair

Millenium

NE/SD

1999

NA

NA

NA

med.

strong

m. short

fair

Morgan

WPB

1996

NA

NA

NA

med.

m. strong

med.

good

Nekota

SD/NE

1997

NA

MS

NA

early

v. strong

v. short

good

Norstar

Can.

1977

Average

S

S

late

med.

tall

good

Nuplains

NE

2000

NA

NA

NA

med.

m. strong

short

fair-poor

Paul

MT

2002

NA

NA

NA

med

med.

med.

fair

Rampart7

MT

1996

NA

S

R

med.

strong

med.

poor

Ransom

ND

1998

Good

R

NA

m. early

med.

med.

good

Rita

SD

1980

Average

MS

MR4

early

strong

med.

fair

Rose

SD

1981

Poor

S

MS4

early

v. strong

short

fair

Roughrider

ND

1975

Good

S

R3

med

m. strong

med.

good

Seward

ND

1987

Poor

S

R

med.

m. strong

med.

good

Tandem

SD

1997

Good

S

NA

early

med.

med.

fair

Wahoo

NE/WY

2001

NA

S

R

med.

m. strong

med.

fair

Wesley

NE/SD/WY

2000

NA

NA

NA

m. early

m. strong

short

fair

Windstar

NE

1997

NA

MS

NA

early

med.

med.

fair-good

NDSU Table 2. Yield (bu/acre) of Winter Wheat at Four Locations in Western N.D.

 

Williston

Dickinson

Hettinger

Minot

Average

Variety

2003

3 Yr. Avg.

20033

3 Yr.

Avg.

2003

3 Yr.

Avg.

2003

3 Yr. Avg.

2003

3 Yr. Avg.

Agassiz

56.0

52.5

74.1

55.5

49.4

47.9

67.2

57.7

61.7

53.4

Alliance

56.3

51.9

65.7

48.4

38.6

54.0

54.5

43.4

53.8

49.4

Arapahoe

54.0

47.9

69.1

54.9

44.4

56.9

74.2

52.9

60.4

53.2

CDC Falcon

58.2

--

83.4

--

52.5

64.1

79.0

56.6

68.3

--

CDC Kestrel

54.6

51.5

80.2

56.1

45.2

54.1

59.0

55.2

59.8

54.2

CDC Raptor

54.3

--

76.5

--

42.3

--

68.1

58.2

60.3

--

Crimson

56.8

43.5

73.8

51.6

44.4

52.8

69.5

56.4

61.1

51.1

Elkhorn

56.2

53.7

73.9

53.8

43.6

47.5

62.7

53.9

59.1

52.2

Expedition

41.5

--

70.8

--

54.2

--

54.0

--

55.1

--

Good Streak

52.2

--

73.4

--

52.7

--

66.4

--

61.2

--

Harding

53.4

51.2

70.3

55.0

54.2

57.6

76.3

58.9

63.5

55.7

Jagalene

46.2

--

76.2

--

18.3

--

86.7

--

56.9

--

Jerry

60.7

57.0

76.7

54.5

51.7

58.3

72.6

59.1

65.4

57.2

McClintock

49.1

--

83.8

--

46.9

--

75.5

 

63.8

--

Millennium

49.2

--

79.4

--

47.5

--

79.0

--

63.8

--

Morgan

60.4

--

80.0

--

40.3

53.6

70.6

--

62.8

--

NeKota

43.9

41.7

59.3

47.3

41.7

56.8

62.7

47.7

51.9

48.4

Norstar

61.5

55.9

81.4

55.3

48.6

50.7

60.6

57.0

63.0

54.7

Paul

48.5

--

84.6

--

51.1

--

65.6

--

62.5

--

Ransom

57.7

51.3

80.3

56.8

43.8

56.4

64.9

63.6

61.7

57.0

Roughrider

53.2

51.2

66.6

45.2

38.0

46.7

65.5

57.5

55.8

50.2

Seward

62.6

58.7

82.5

52.9

39.2

46.1

64.5

56.2

62.2

53.5

Tandem

48.6

45.4

63.3

44.9

47.3

52.7

70.9

58.8

57.5

50.5

Wahoo

56.4

--

83.3

--

47.7

--

80.1

--

66.9

--

Wesley

38.6

--

65.9

--

37.2

--

70.2

50.8

53.0

--

Windstar

51.6

47.7

69.1

51.4

47.9

52.3

70.8

56.2

59.8

51.9

Mean

53.3

50.7

74.7

52.2

44.9

53.4

68.9

55.6

60.5

52.8

NDSU Table 3. Yield of Winter Wheat Grown At Three Locations in Eastern ND

 

Carrington

Langdon

Casselton

Average

State Avg.

Variety

2003

3 Yr. Avg.

2003

3 Yr. Avg.

2003

3 yr.1 Avg.

2003

2003

3 Yr.2 Avg.

2003

3 Yr.

 Avg.

Agassiz

49.6

49.7

83.3

64.8

56.8

55.4

36.1

56.5

56.6

59.1

54.8

Alliance

60.6

50.5

105.3

75.7

52.7

62.2

34.3

63.2

62.8

58.5

55.1

Arapahoe

65.0

54.4

96.4

80.3

61.5

68.4

56.1

69.8

67.7

65.1

59.4

CDC Falcon

61.3

54.6

97.6

82.1

63.0

--

46.4

67.1

--

67.7

--

CDC Kestrel

63.0

57.2

93.3

75.2

71.2

72.3

53.3

70.2

68.2

65.0

60.2

CDC Raptor

66.6

57.1

92.2

75.0

56.2

--

49.3

66.1

--

63.2

--

Crimson

56.7

42.7

93.9

70.6

58.1

58.6

42.2

62.7

57.3

61.9

53.8

Elkhorn

56.2

53.0

89.1

73.7

59.5

55.9

48.9

63.4

60.9

61.3

55.9

Expedition

59.9

--

100.6

--

50.4

--

43.1

63.5

--

59.3

--

Good Streak

69.0

--

105.1

--

61.2

--

56.5

73.0

--

67.1

--

Harding

53.7

51.4

92.9

78.2

59.5

64.9

55.7

65.5

64.8

64.5

59.6

Jagalene

63.3

--

99.2

--

35.5

--

66.8

66.2

--

61.5

--

Jerry

66.1

--

95.9

78.6

62.5

--

63.7

72.1

--

68.8

--

McClintock

66.1

55.0

98.0

--

44.7

--

49.8

64.7

--

64.3

--

Millennium

66.7

51.5

100.6

83.0

54.0

--

74.9

74.1

--

69.0

--

Morgan

72.6

58.7

96.7

72.5

66.7

--

44.5

70.1

--

66.5

--

NeKota

51.7

42.4

95.2

72.5

51.3

62.7

41.1

59.8

59.2

55.9

53.0

Norstar

56.6

53.9

88.7

62.1

63.8

50.2

41.9

62.8

55.4

62.9

55.0

Paul

50.3

--

91.3

--

58.6

--

33.1

58.3

--

60.4

--

Ransom

59.3

55.5

93.3

75.0

55.9

66.6

47.3

64.0

65.7

62.9

60.7

Roughrider

49.8

49.4

90.3

66.7

56.4

47.8

38.2

58.7

54.6

57.3

52.1

Seward

50.0

52.4

87.0

66.0

62.1

49.6

36.2

58.8

56.0

60.5

54.6

Tandem

65.3

50.1

93.9

71.9

49.9

65.5

51.3

65.1

62.5

61.3

55.6

Wahoo

62.7

--

99.8

--

53.5

--

52.4

67.1

--

67.0

--

Wesley

61.4

--

101.2

76.9

46.2

--

60.1

67.2

--

60.1

--

Windstar

56.3

--

88.5

75.2

63.2

62.8

42.0

62.5

--

61.2

--

Mean

60.0

52.2

95.0

74.3

56.7

60.2

48.7

65.4

60.9

62.8

56.1

NDSU Table 4. Protein Percent of Winter Wheat Varieties Grown in 2003 at Eight Locations in ND.

Variety

Williston

Dickinson

Hettinger

Minot

Carrington

Langdon

Casselton

Lisbon

Average

Agassiz

14.4

14.3

15.3

15.1

12.4

13.6

11.6

13.1

13.7

Alliance

13.3

12.6

14.1

13.1

11.3

11.4

11.5

12.2

12.4

Arapahoe

14.1

13.8

14.8

14.0

12.3

12.8

11.8

13.6

13.4

CDC Falcon

13.0

12.9

15.2

14.0

12.0

11.8

12.2

13.1

13.0

CDC Kestrel

12.3

12.5

14.7

14.1

10.6

11.3

10.6

12.2

12.3

CDC Raptor

12.8

13.2

15.1

14.0

11.5

11.6

11.6

13.0

12.9

Crimson

14.1

13.9

14.5

14.3

12.3

12.8

12.3

13.0

13.4

Elkhorn

13.4

13.5

15.3

14.7

12.3

12.6

11.5

13.7

13.4

Expedition

13.8

13.3

14.2

12.9

12.0

12.1

12.2

12.5

12.9

Good Streak

14.0

13.5

14.9

14.0

12.1

12.6

11.9

13.9

13.7

Harding

13.8

13.9

14.9

14.0

12.3

13.0

12.2

13.6

13.5

Jagalene

14.6

13.9

15.0

13.5

12.9

12.7

14.0

13.5

13.8

Jerry

13.5

13.5

14.8

13.7

11.9

12.4

12.1

13.1

13.1

McClintock

13.7

13.5

14.5

13.8

11.5

12.3

12.1

13.0

13.1

Millennium

13.7

13.8

14.0

13.6

11.9

12.1

12.6

12.9

13.1

Morgan

13.0

13.3

15.0

14.8

11.2

11.8

10.7

12.3

12.8

NeKota

14.5

13.9

14.0

13.8

12.1

12.7

11.8

12.6

13.2

Norstar

12.9

13.5

15.3

14.7

11.7

12.5

10.3

12.6

12.9

Paul

13.8

13.4

15.2

14.8

12.1

12.4

10.8

13.6

13.3

Ransom

12.9

13.1

14.8

14.1

11.6

12.2

11.5

13.4

13.0

Roughrider

13.8

14.1

15.0

14.8

12.4

13.0

12.0

13.9

13.6

Seward

12.9

13.4

15.3

14.4

11.5

12.5

10.0

12.4

12.8

Tandem

15.0

14.9

14.6

14.5

12.6

13.2

12.3

13.6

13.8

Wahoo

13.3

13.0

15.1

13.5

11.8

12.0

12.2

13.2

13.0

Wesley

15.0

13.9

15.6

14.0

12.8

13.0

13.8

13.6

14.0

Windstar

14.3

13.9

14.4

14.0

12.8

13.7

12.5

14.4

13.8

Mean

13.6

13.5

14.7

14.0

12.0

12.5

11.9

13.2

13.2

More Winter Wheat Information Online

NDSU Small Grain Publications: www.ext.nodak.edu/extpubs/smgrains.htm

Montana State University Winter Wheat Information: http://plantsciences.montana.edu/Crops/winterwheat/default.htm

SDSU 2004 Variety Recommendations/2003Crop Performance Results: http://agbiopubs.sdstate.edu/articles/EC774-04.pdf

Ducks Unlimited Winter Wheat Management Tips
Ducks Unlimited encourages winter wheat production in the Prairie Pothole Region, since the crop provides excellent habitat for nesting.  DU also points out that winter wheat can help spread farm workload, offers greater soil moisture recharge potential from an early-harvested crop, and reduces soil erosion.

The web site for the regional DU office is http://prairie.ducks.org . There, click on the link “Agronomy News” for solid winter wheat research and production information (see archives) coordinated by DU agronomists Blake VanderVorst and Roger Knapp. The two recently compiled winter wheat management tips into a brochure, condensed below. 

1) Plan to seed the winter wheat directly into residue-managed standing canola, flax, oat or barley stubble for best results. Seeding winter wheat in hard red spring wheat stubble is acceptable, but expect more disease pressure from early season tan spot.

2) Standing stubble needs to have the capability to trap at least two inches of snow to ensure winter survival. The standing stubble from a prior cereal or flax crop should be eight inches tall or taller after seeding the winter wheat. A previous canola crop requires a stubble height of 12 inches. A previous crop stubble height of 12 to 16 inches optimizes winter wheat survival. Consideration should be given to the prior crop variety’s straw strength to assure as much standing residue as possible.

3) Make sure the combine is uniformly spreading crop straw and chaff residues to allow the drill/seeder to attain good seed to soil contact and avoid hair-pinning with disk openers. Straw concentration is generally acceptable when spread over 80% of the width of the cut, while chaff should be spread over 60% of the width of cut. Use of harrows to spread crop residues is not recommended because the standing stubble may be knocked down or weakened, reducing its ability to trap snow and protect the winter wheat seedling.

4) Control grassy weeds and volunteer crops two weeks prior to seeding winter wheat to eliminate the “green bridge” to manage the disease wheat streak mosaic. Wheat streak mosaic is spread by the wheat curl mite, which has a life cycle of about one week. Grassy weeds and volunteer crops are hosts for the mite. Eliminating the grassy hosts breaks the life cycle of the mite and stops the spread of the disease.

5) Direct seed into standing stubble during the optimal seeding period (September 1-30). Seeding early in the time period results in a more developed winter wheat crown and a vigorous plant that will have a greater ability to survive the winter and mature early. Early seeding requires top management to avoid wheat streak mosaic.

6) A 1-inch seeding depth is preferred. Seed at a rate of 1.2 to 1.5 million pure live seeds per acre. Date of seeding impacts seeding rate and depth. Higher seeding rates after mid-September may compensate for stand loss from winterkill resulting from reduced seedling crown development. Seeding shallow will hasten plant emergence and crown development. Pay close attention to seed to soil contact and soil coverage. Insufficient soil coverage of the seed can adversely affect winter survival.

7) Soil test and apply phosphate ertilizer with the seed or in a band to enhance plant development and winter survival.

8) Canadian research has shown that early spring application (April) of nitrogen fertilizers provides the most consistent results. The opportunity to enhance winter wheat yield diminishes the later the nitrogen is applied. Some wheat growers apply a portion of their nitrogen at seeding or in the fall as wet soil conditions can delay early spring application. North Dakota and Montana research indicates that 2.3 pounds of nitrogen per bushel is required to attain 12% protein winter wheat. There are three nitrogen products available for surface application: ammonium nitrate, urea ammonium nitrate, and urea. They are listed in order of increasing potential for volatility.

9) Current winter wheat varieties are moderately susceptible to disease and have responded positively to fungicides.  Timely fungicide applications to winter wheat planted in spring wheat stubble controls foliar and head disease resulting in higher yields and better grain quality. NDSU research trials conducted from 2001 to 2003 indicate that split fungicide applications have been the most consistent in increasing winter wheat yields. The first fungicide application is tank mixed with the herbicide and the second treatment applied at early flower or Feekes 10.51 stage of growth.  The early fungicide application is usually not required for winter wheat planted in a broadleaf crop residue.

10) Control of volunteer winter wheat is critical following the winter wheat crop to prevent the spread of wheat streak mosaic and other green-bridge diseases. Following winter wheat with a broadleaf crop can also reduce the risk of wheat streak mosaic.  Winter annual weeds require special attention in winter cereal crops as they have the same growth habit.

Managing Hard White Wheat
Hard white wheat is essentially identical to hard red wheat with the exception of the genes that affect kernel color. Therefore, management practices that are good for hard red wheat are good for hard white wheat.  There are, however, a few areas of special concern for white wheat.

All currently available adapted white wheat varieties are susceptible to Fusarium head blight (scab).  This does not mean that resistance cannot be bred into white wheat varieties in the future, but that those that are currently available lack the resistant genes of varieties like Alsen. Therefore, if the environment is conducive to the development of scab, plan on applying an approved fungicide to control scab damage. Leaf rust is also likely to be a problem on most varieties and may require control with fungicides.

For hard white wheat intended for bread making, high protein is required, (i.e. Argent and AC Vista),  so N management should be similar to that used for HRSW. Lower protein (10-12%) is required in varieties (like Lolo) grown for the noodle market, so late-in-the-season applications of N should be avoided and basal N rates be more conservative.

Pre-harvest sprouting can be a problem in white wheat. Of course, sprouting can also be a problem in red wheat if conditions are conducive to germination, but white wheat varieties tend to be more susceptible to sprouting problems than their HRSW counterparts.  White wheat should be harvested in a timely manner.  Certainly you should harvest your white wheat before any HRSW of similar maturity in order to reduce the risk of pre-harvest sprouting. Finally, white wheat should be kept identity-preserved by segregating it from red wheat. 

– Joel Ransom, NDSU
extension agronomist