Issue 62
Prairie Grains

Library

Home

E-Mail

Back

Prairie Grains is the official publication of the Minnesota Association of Wheat Growers, North Dakota Grain Growers Association, Montana Grain Growers Association and South Dakota Wheat, Inc.

Copyright Prairie Grains Magazine
June 2004

Weed Management

How Weeds Can Rob Wheat Yields

Weeds/sq. yard

Foxtail

Wild Oat

 % wheat yield reduction

10

0

8-9%

50

4-5%

18%

75

6-7%

25%

100

8-9%

34%

150

15%

40%

How Weeds Can Affect Wheat

  • Ten wild oats or wild mustard plants per square foot will reduce wheat yields 10-20 bushels per acre or 35%.
  • Two to three kochia plants per square foot can reduce yields 30%.
  • Canada thistle patches often reduce yields by 60%.
  • Green foxtail can reduce yields 10-15% when wheat is planted late.

Source: NDSU

Organic Matter, Spray Water Can Affect Herbicide Performance
Some herbicides are partially adsorbed and inactivated by soil organic matter, both high and low. Thus, test organic matter to help make herbicide product decisions. OM levels change very slowly, so testing once every 5 years should be adequate.

Spray carrier water can also reduce the effectiveness of herbicides. Water high in sodium bicarbonate reduces the effectiveness of 2,4-D and MCPA amines (not esters), Poast, glyphosate, and dicamba. High salt levels in spray water can reduce weed control in nearly all situations. Calcium and, to a lesser degree, magnesium are antagonistic to 2,4-D and MCPA amine, dicamba, and glyphosate. Analysis of spray water sources will determine possible effects on herbicide efficacy. Water samples can be tested (for about $25) at the following laboratory: NDSU Soil and Water Environmental Laboratory, (701) 231-7864, Waldron 202, NDSU, Fargo, ND 58105-5575.

Glyphosate Rates
Don’t push the envelope as far as application timing or reduced rates with glyphosate-resistant crops, or weed control may be sacrificed. Use higher labeled rates on larger weeds, in dry conditions (weeds under moisture stress are harder to kill) and weeds that are more difficult to control with glyphosate, such as nightshades and wild buckwheat.  Keep in mind that not all glyphosate products are equal; for example, some require an additional non-ionic surfactant, while no additional NIS is needed with other products.  Follow the label.

Follow The Apples Sequence When Tank Mixing
The NDSU Extension Service recommends the A.P.P.L.E.S. sequence for adding herbicide formulations to a tank partially filled with water: A gitate, Powders soluble, Powders dry, Liquid flowables and suspensions, mulsifiable concentrates and Solutions. Add surfactants, petroleum oils, MSO (methylated seed oil) type and other adjuvants last.

Tips for Controlling Weeds In Dry Weather
Weeds do not grow as quickly in dry conditions and metabolism is slowed. Many weeds are shallow rooted and stop growing in dry soil. Perennial weeds may handle drought better because underground roots can tap into moisture deeper in the soil profile.

This does not mean perennials will not be affected by drought. Look at leaf composition: plants grown in dry conditions have smaller leaves and develop a thicker cuticle which amounts into less droplets intercepting leaves and less herbicide absorbed.

Superior adjuvants can help overcome leaf barriers like thick cuticle. Most POST herbicides used are translocated, so movement through the cuticle and then through the plant to growing points are critical for adequate control.

Where product labels permit, addition of crop oil concentrate rather than nonionic surfactant usually results in greater herbicide activity. Some products also allow for N-based spray additives, which tend to improve efficacy of certain products during periods of slight stress.

Dust is another problem and can inactivate many herbicides. That is why poor control can be seen behind tractor tires and along gravel roads. Reducing herbicide rates is not a good idea during prolonged dry weather. For best results, use the highest recommended rate and use superior adjuvants if allowed on the label.

 Consider spot spraying—wild oat patches, for example—if crop quality and quantity is poor and in jeopardy and may not justify complete field spraying. 

Applying herbicides in the early morning (except glyphosate) may improve weed control in dry conditions. During the night, the plant has recovered some from the heat and stress of the previous day. The leaves may not be wilted as much, increasing the leaf’s surface area. The dew may help to keep spray droplets hydrated longer allowing better absorption.

Outside of proper calibration, good working components, and quality nozzles, there is not much to improve performance from your sprayer in dry conditions.

Puma and Discover have greater efficacy in cool, moist conditions and Assert and Everest have greater efficacy in hot, dry conditions.

Essentially all postemergence herbicides have a statement on the label regarding weed growth and environmental conditions. A typical example is “Do not apply to grasses or crops under stress such as stress due to lack of moisture...as unsatisfactory control may result.” To attain adequate control, weeds must be actively growing and must not exceed the maximum growth stage.

For some weeds, delaying postemergence control efforts until moisture stress is relieved is not feasible. Many postemergence treatments are effective only on small weeds, and small weeds are always easier to control than larger ones. For weeds under drought stress, use the highest labeled rates for the herbicides and possibly alter adjuvants if label allows.

The decision of delaying a herbicide application and waiting for a rain or spraying drought-stressed weeds is debatable. Control is generally unsatisfactory when weeds are drought-stressed, but delaying an application often allows the weeds to get too big, making control even more difficult. Making this decision must be done on a field-by-field basis.

If rainfall is in the immediate forecast, post-emergence herbicide activity will be maximized by waiting until after rain to apply, but large drought-stressed weeds can be extremely difficult to control. Where there appears to be no rain coming, apply when weeds are small for best activity. A later application may be required if late rain stimulates a new flush of weeds.

Follow label directions and remember every product is different.

—Bev Durgan, U of M extension weed specialist, Richard Zollinger, NDSU extension weed specialist

Reducing Spray Drift
Apply when wind direction is away from susceptible plants, when velocity is 10 mph or less.

Adjust boom as close to the target as possible while maintaining uniform spray coverage.  Choose nozzles with a wide angle over narrow angle nozzles.

Several sprayer nozzles designed to reduce spray drift are available. These nozzles increase spray droplet size and reduce the number of small droplets. These drift -reducing nozzles are flat-fan types and are adapted for conventional spray equipment. The two primary types of drift-reducing nozzles are pre-orifice and veturi designs.

Some herbicides volatilize under warm or hot temperature and cause plant injury from vapors or fume drift. Temperature on the soil surface often is several degrees warmer than air temperature. Herbicide vapor can drift further and over a longer time than spray droplets. Wind blowing away from susceptible plants during application will prevent damage from droplet drift but a later wind shift toward the susceptible plants could move damaging vapors to the plants.

Low volatile esters of 2,4-D or MCPA may produce damaging vapors between 70 to 90 F. Amine formulations are essentially non-volatile even at high temperatures. To minimize the risk of drift injury, dicamba and ester formulations of 2,4-D and MCPA should not be used near susceptible plants.

Small plastic cones that fit around individual nozzles reduce drift by approximately 25 to 50% and spray shields which enclose the entire boom reduce drift by approximately 50 to 85%. Spray shields provide greater drift reduction when winds are low and droplets are relatively large. Therefore, spray shields should not be used as a substitute for other drift control techniques but as a supplement to all other applicable methods of drift reduction.

Spray drift can be reduced by increasing droplet size and droplet size can be increased by reducing spray pressure, increasing nozzle orifice size, special drift reduction nozzles, additives that increase spray viscosity, and rearward nozzle orientation on aircraft.

For more detailed information on managing spray and vapor drift, efer to NDSU Extension Circular A-657, “Herbicide Spray Drift” and Circular WC-751 “Documentation for Suspected Herbicide Drift Damage,” both of which can be found on the Internet under NDSU online weed control publications: www.ext .nodak.edu/extpubs/weeds.htm .

Minimum Interval Between Application and Rain for Maximum POST Weed Control


Herbicide

Time
Interval


Herbicide

Time
Interval

Accent

4-6 hr

Liberty ATZ

4 hr

Accent Gold/WDG

6 hr

Lightning

1 hr

Achieve/Liquid

1 hr

Lorox

6-8 hr

Aim DF/EW

1 hr

Lumax

4 hr

Ally/XP / Cimarron

4 hr

MCPA amine

4 hr

Ally Extra

6 hr

MCPA ester

1 hr

Amber

4 hr

Marksman

4 hr

Assert

3 hr

Matrix

4 hr

Assure II

1 hr

Maverick

4 hr

Atrazine*

4 hr

Muster

4-6 hr

Avenge

6 hr

Northstar

4 hr

Basagran

4 hr

Option

2 hr

Basis

4 hr

Paramount

6 hr

Basis Gold

4-6 hr

Peak

1 hr

Betamix/Betanex

6 hr

Permit

4 hr

Beyond

1 hr

Phoenix

2 hr

Bromoxynil

1 hr

Plateau

1 hr

Bronate Advanced

1 hr

Poast

1 hr

Butyrac 200

6 hr

Prism

1 hr

Callisto

1 hr

Progress

6 hr

Celebrity Plus

4-6 hr

Pursuit

1 hr

Cimarron Max

4 hr

Puma

1 hr

Clarity

6-8 hr

Raptor

1 hr

Cobra

0.5 hr

Rave

4 hr

Curtail/M

6 hr

ReadyMaster ATZ

4 hr

Dakota

1 hr

Redeem

2 hr

Desicate II

5 hr

Reflex

1 hr

Dicamba

6-8 hr

Reglone

0.5 hr

Distinct

4 hr

Rely

4 hr

Discover/NG

1 hr

Remedy

6-8 hr

Diquat

0.5 hr

Rezult

4 hr

Engame

4-6 hr

RT Master/GlyMixMT

4-6 hr

Everest

1 hr

RU Custom

4-6 hr

Express/XP

4 hr

RU Original/RT

4 hr

Extreme

1 hr

RU Original II

1-2 hr

Finesse

4 hr

RU Private Labels

4-6 hr

FirstRate

4 hr

Roundup Ultra Max

1 hr

Flexstar

1 hr

RU Weather Max

0.5 hr

Fuego

4 hr

Select

1 hr

Fusilade DX

1 hr

Sencor

6-8 hr

Fusion

1 hr

Stampede 80EDF

4 hr

Galaxy

6 hr

Starane

1 hr

Glean

4 hr

Steadfast

4-6 hr

Glyphosate (Full adj.)

1-2 hr

Stinger

6 hr

Glyphosate (Part adj.)

4 hr

Storm

6 hr

Glyphosate (No adj.)

4-6 hr

Teamwork

1 hr

Goal

1 hr

Tordon 22K

6-8 hr

Gramoxone Max

0.5 hr

Touchdown CF/iQ

1 hr

Harmony Extra/XP

4 hr

Ultra Blazer

6 hr

Harmony GT/XP

4 hr

UpBeet

6 hr

Hornet/WDG

6 hr

Weedmaster

6-8 hr

Landmaster BW

6-12 hr

2,4-D amine

4 hr

 

 

2,4-D ester

1 hr

Clean Sprayer Properly Cut Crop Injury Potential
Rinsing with water is not adequate to remove all herbicide residues. Some herbicides have remained tightly adsorbed in sprayers through water rinsing, and even through several tank-loads of other herbicides. Then, when a tank-load of solution including an oil adjuvant or nitrogen solution was put in the sprayer, the herbicide was desorbed, moved into the spray solution, and damaged susceptible crops. Highly active herbicides that have been difficult to wash from sprayers and have caused crop injury include dicamba, Pursuit, Raptor and sulfonylurea herbicides.

Proper sprayer cleanout procedures are given on many herbicide labels and the procedure on the label should be followed for specific herbicides. The following procedure illustrating a thorough sprayer cleanup procedure is effective for most herbicides:

Step 1. Drain tank and thoroughly rinse interior surfaces of tank with clean water. Spray rinse water through the spray boom. Sufficient rinse water should be used for 5 minutes or more of spraying through the boom.

Step 2. Fill the sprayer tank with clean water and add a cleaning solution (many labels provide recommended cleaning solutions). Fill the boom, hoses, and nozzles and allow the agitator to operate for 15 minutes.

Step 3. Allow the sprayer to sit for 8 hours while full of cleaning solution so the herbicide can be fully desorbed from the residues inside the sprayer.

Step 4. Spray the cleaning solution through the booms.

Step 5. Clean nozzles, screens, and filters. Rinse the sprayer to remove cleaning solution and spray rinsate through the booms.

Common types of cleaning solutions are chlorine bleach, ammonia, and commercially formulated tank cleaners. Chlorine lowers the pH of the solution, which speeds the degradation of some herbicides. Ammonia increases the pH of the solution, which increases the solubility of some herbicides. Commercially formulated tank cleaners generally raise pH and act as detergents to remove herbicides. Read herbicide label for recommended tank cleaning solutions and procedures. Never mix chlorine bleach and ammonia, as a dangerous and irritating gas will be released.

Sprayers should be cleaned as soon as possible after use to prevent the deposit of dried spray residues. A sprayer should not remain empty overnight without cleaning; fill the tank with water to prevent dried spray deposits from forming.

Source: NDSU

Sprayer Cleaning Solutions For Herbicides
Ammonia + Water:
Accent, Ally, Amber, Assure II, Basis, Basis Gold, Beacon, dicamba, Exceed, Expert, Finesse, FirstRate, Glean, Peak, Permit, Harmony GT, Python, Resolve, Stinger.

Kerosene or diesel fuel followed by ammonia + water: 2,4-D ester

Ammonia or commercial tank cleaner + water: Action, Basagran, Bladex, Buctril + Atra, bromoxynil, Callisto, Classic, Cobra, Contour, Dual/II/Magnum, Flexstar, Fusilade DX, Fusion, Gauntlet, Gramoxone, Harness, Harmony Extra, Hornet, Lasso, Lightning, Moxy, Moxynil, Passport, Prowl, Pursuit, Pursuit Plus, Reflex, Resource, Scepter, Select, Squadron, Status, Steel, Surpass, Treflan, trifluralin, and Ultra Blazer.

Water: Command and glyphosate.

Detergent + water: Atrazine and Sencor.

Commercial tank cleaner + water: Liberty, Marksman, Optill, Shotgun, and Touchdown

Detergent or commercial tank cleaner + water: Turbo

Ammonia, commercial tank cleaner, or detergent + water: Poast.

Baking soda (1 to 2;b / 100 gal water): Engame

Compatibility Test for Pesticide Mixtures
Under federal law, combining pesticides is legal unless the pesticide labeling of any of the pesticides involved instructs you not to combine them. However, not all pesticides work well when mixed together. They must be compatible — that is, mixing them together must not reduce their safety or effectiveness. The more pesticides you mix together, the greater the chance of undesirable effects.

A way to test for tankmix compatability:

  1. Get a large, clean, clear glass container, such as a quart jar. Use the same water (or other diluent) that you will use when making up the larger mixture. Add the water and each of the products in the same proportions as you will mix them. For example, each quart of pesticide that you add to 50 gallons of final spray mixture is the equivalent of about 1 teaspoon per quart of water. Unless the pesticide labeling states otherwise, add pesticides to the diluent using the “W-A-L-E” plan:
    1.  --Add some of the diluent first

       --Add Wettable and other powders and Water-dispersible granules

       --Agitate thoroughly and add the remaining diluent.

       --Add the Liquid products, such as solutions, surfactants, and flowables.

        --Add Emulsifiable concentrates last.

       

  2.  Shake the jar vigorously. Feel the sides of the jar to determine if the mixture is giving off heat. If so, the mixture may be undergoing a chemical reaction and the pesticides should not be combined. Let the mixture stand for about 15 minutes and feel again for unusual heat.

If scum forms on the surface, if the mixture clumps, or if any solids settle to the bottom (except for wettable powders), the mixture probably is not compatible. Finally, if no signs of incompatibility appear, test the mixture on a small area of the surface where it is to be applied.

  1. Resolving Incompatibility
    Add 6 drops of compatibility agent and stir well. If mixture appears compatible, allow it to stand for 1 hour, stir well, and check it again. If the mixture appears incompatible, repeat one or two more times, using 6 drops of compatibility agent each time.
  2. If incompatibility still persists, dispose of this mixture, clean the jar, and repeat the above steps, but add 6 drops of compatibility agent to the water before anything else is added.
  3. If the mixture is still incompatible, do not mix the chemicals in the spray tank.

To over come this problem you might consider the following alternatives:

    a) Use a different water supply. Hard water can contribute to incompatibility.

    b) Change brands or formulations of chemicals.

    c) Change the order of mixing.

Make only one change at a time, and perform a complete test, as described above, before making another change. Do not mix the chemicals in the spray tank if incompatibility cannot be resolved.

Wear personal protective equipment when pouring or mixing pesticides. Perform this test in a safe area away from food and sources of ignition. Pesticides used in this test should be put into the spray tank when completed. Rinse all utensils and jars and pour the rinse water (rinsate) into the spray tank. Do not use utensils or jars for any other purpose after they have contacted pesticides.

– Montana State University Extension Service

Strategies To Minimize Herbicide Resistant Weeds
The following strategies should be effective in reducing problems with herbicide tolerant and resistant weed biotypes, but no strategy is likely to be totally effective alone.

  • Scout fields regularly and identify weeds that escape herbicide treatment. Monitor changes in weed populations and restrict spread of potentially resistant weeds that match the field history and herbicide pattern.
  • Rotate herbicides with different modes of action in consecutive years.
  • Apply herbicides in tank-mix, prepackage or sequential mixtures that include multiple modes of action. Two or more herbicides in the tank-mix must have substantial activity against potentially resistant weeds. Most commercial premixes do not contain herbicides that target the same weed species.
  • Rotate crops, particularly those with different life cycles, e.g., winter annual crops (winter wheat), perennial crops (alfalfa), summer annual (spring wheat, corn or beans). Do not use herbicides with the same mode of action in the different crops unless other effective control practices are also included.

For a comprehensive list of resistant weeds in North Dakota, U.S., and world see web site: www.weedscience.com .

– Richard Zollinger, NDSU

Weed Info Online

North Dakota State University: www.ag.ndsu.nodak.edu/weeds (with link to weed I.D.)

South Dakota State University: http://plantsci.sdstate.edu/weeds/

University of Minnesota: (see link “MN Weed Research Reports” for product performance results for various crops) http://appliedweeds.coafes.umn.edu

Weed Science Society of America: www.wssa.net (includes link to weed photos and I.D.)

Considerations In Preharvest Weed Control
Lack of soil applied herbicides, herbicides applied later than recommended, flushes of weeds emerging after application, poor weed control from weather, and environmental conditions promoting excellent weed growth conditions contribute to weedy small grain fields. An excellent opportunity for weed burn down, perennial weed control and harvest aid is through preharvest herbicide application. However, following are some factors to consider before applying a herbicide as a harvest aid:

  • The expectations for preharvest weed control usually exceed reality - it is not possible to kill\dry down a three-foot weed in the same manner as a three-inch weed. Lower portions of the weed may not be affected.
  • It requires time to dry down treated weeds - usually 7-10 days. It may require more time if wet and/or cool weather conditions occur after treatment. All herbicides labeled for preharvest application are systemic and slow acting which requires a longer dry down period as compared to contact, fast acting herbicides.
  • The intent of a preharvest treatment should be to facilitate harvest and reduce harvest loss. Preharvest treatments do not decrease yield losses due to weed competition or prevent weed seed production.
  • Consider sensitive crops (sugarbeets, potatoes, etc.) and other plants (trees, gardens, etc.) in the general vicinity of the field receiving treatment, which may be at risk to herbicide drift.
  • Note that paraquat is not labeled as a harvest aid in small grains.

 – Richard Zollinger, NDSU Extension Service

Herbicide Storage Temperatures
Herbicides may be exposed to freezing temperatures in storage. The following products have no storage temperature restrictions: Dual products, EPTC, Surpass , Achieve, Maverick. Most dry formulated herbicides in DF or WDG formulations.  Most others have restrictions below 40 F, to a varying degree.  Check the label and store accordingly.

Silverado New Wild Oat Herbicide Option For Wheat
Silverado™ is a new wild oat herbicide on the market this year from Bayer CropScience for postemergence control of wild oats in wheat (including durum) in North Dakota, South Dakota, Minnesota and eastern Montana.

The product contains the active ingredient mesosulfuron-methyl that controls wild oats with a new mode of action, more rotational options and excellent crop safety. The product also controls wild mustard and volunteer canola, and suppresses green foxtail, Persian darnel and redroot pigweed.

Cost is about $8.75 per acre plus adjuvants. It is not persistent in the soil, allowing growers to plant sugar beets, potatoes, sunflowers, soybeans, lentils or other crops the following season. Corn may be planted 12 months after Silverado is applied.

The product is a 2% water dispersible granule formulation that includes a safener designed specifically for wheat. It may be applied postemergence at rates of 1.75 ounces to 2.25 ounces per acre to actively growing wild oats in the one-leaf to two-tiller stage of growth. The new herbicide has a wide window of application from wheat emergence to the jointing stage. It may be tankmixed with other broadleaf herbicides; follow label directions.

Bayer CropScience has more information about Silverado online: www.cerealexperts.com