Issue 52
Prairie Grains

Library

Home

E-Mail

Back

Prairie Grains is the official publication of the Minnesota Association of Wheat Growers, North Dakota Grain Growers Association, Montanta Grain Growers Association and South Dakota Wheat, Inc.

Copyright Prairie Grains Magazine
April  2003

Wells Fargo Ag Economist: Markets Buoyed by Bullish, Bearish Factors

If moisture conditions stay dry, the markets will have to start building in additional risk premium given the poor soil moisture conditions and low stocks. 

On the flip side, however, a significant improvement in the drought stress outlook would bring a major drop in the current future prices, especially given significant worldwide grain production competition, according to Michael Swanson, agricultural economist, Wells Fargo, Minneapolis, Minn.

“For most producers, the greatest risk is not missing the top of the market, but being stuck at the low prices,” he says. Swanson was a speaker at South Dakota State University’s annual Commodity Price Outlook conference, held recently in Brookings.

  Additional risk comes from the current counter-cyclical payment situation. Swanson says the worst possible scenario for CCP is for the price to be exactly equal to the trigger price.  This would mean no counter-cyclical payment and no opportunities to forward price at better levels. 

The current expectation is for a muted acreage response in the spring wheat regions, says Swanson, as many producers have introduced corn and soybeans into their rotations over the last five years and are not eager to go back to heavier wheat rotations. For the moment, the only reasonable forecast is for a recovery to trendline yield, with a negative risk factor from the current soil moisture outlook.

“The key for most producers will be knowing when to say when.  Producers need to know with a high degree of precision and certainty their cost of production,” says Swanson. “When the market has reached their cost of production and allowed some margin, they should lock in a reasonably significant portion of their forward sales.”

Swanson outlines bullish and bearish conditions for wheat, corn, and soybeans:

Wheat
Expected Price Range into February, 2004: $3.60 to $4.00 for all wheat

BULLISH

  • Questionable winter wheat conditions
  • Drought stress continues in key growing regions and countries
  • A weaker dollar against the Euro, Canada and Australia does help U.S. exports
  • Declining domestic and global stocks

BEARISH
FSU countries continue to ramp up production of both feed and milling wheat

  • Expected return to more typical world yields in the current year

Soybeans
Expected Price Range into February, 2004:  $4.90 to $6.25

BULLISH

  • Low stocks
  • Excellent usage
  • Flat to falling acreage

BEARISH

  • Increasing South American production
  • Weaker dollar will not help soybeans - China remains in fixed exchange rate with the U.S. and Argentina, and Brazil’s currencies are so weak that no amount of weakening will help

Corn
Expected Price Range into February, 2004:  $2.20 to 2.75 per bushel

BULLISH

  • Low stocks - excellent usage
  • Drought stress increasing risk
  • South American acreage flat to falling

BEARISH

  • Chinese exports continue to take U.S. market share
  • Expected increase in U.S. acreage
  • Expected return to trendline yields
  • Weaker dollar offers little support for corn

Do You Know Your Breakeven Price?
To evaluate what may or may not be a fair selling price for your grain, it only makes sense that you know your breakeven price.

George Flaskerud, North Dakota State University extension ag economist, says that breakeven price varies by region and by farm.  However, it can generally be calculated by dividing total cost (farm and family living expenses) by average or expected yield to arrive at a per-bushel-yield price.

Flaskerud offers an analysis for the northern Red River Valley as an example, arriving at a “survival price” and an “acceptable price” for wheat, corn, and soybeans.

The survival price is an estimate of income needed to recover farm and family living cash expenses, excluding farm program payments.  The acceptable price accounts for indirect costs as well, including interest paid on land and equipment, depreciation, and other overhead expenses.

He bases total cash costs figured under the survival price, and total economic costs under the acceptable price, on assumptions used by NDSU to establish crop budget projections for 2003, which can be found online at www.ext.nodak.edu/extpubs/ecguides.htm .

He uses a figure of $20/acre for family living based on an estimated average of $40,000 and average cropland from 2000. The $11 estimate for additional land cost accounts for owned and rented land, and assumes 70% of land is rented. The $11 government payment is the average direct payment for a typical farm in ND, estimated to vary between $9 - $15/acre, depending on that farm’s base acreage.

See an update on grain marketing strategies to consider from Flaskerud at his crop marketing and risk management web site, www.ag.ndsu.nodak.edu/aginfo/cropmkt/cropmkt.htm .  On the home page, click on the link “Update on Marketing Strategies for Old Crop and New.”

Breakeven Price for Wheat, Northern Red River Valley, 2003

Survival price

  • Total cash costs of $127 plus $11 additional land cost plus $20 for family living less $11 government payments
  • Divided by yield of 38 bushels per acre
  • Equals $3.87 per bushel

Acceptable price

  • Total economic costs of $144 plus $20 for family living less $11 government payments
  • Divided by yield of 38 bushels per acre
  • Equals $4.03 per bushel

Breakeven Price for Corn, Northern Red River Valley, 2003

Survival price

  • Total cash costs of $196 plus $11 land cost plus $20 for family living less $11 govt pmts
  • Divided by yield of 95 bushels per acre
  • Equals $2.27 per bushel

Acceptable price

  • Total economic costs of $213 plus $20 for family living less $11 govt pmts
  • Divided by yield of 95 bushels per acre
  • Equals $2.34 per bushel

Breakeven Price for Soybeans, Northern Red River Valley, 2003

Survival price

  • Total cash costs of $118 plus $11 additional land cost plus $20 for family living less $11 government payments
  • Divided by yield of 29 bushels per acre
  • Equals $4.76 per bushel

Acceptable price

  • Total economic costs of $136 plus $20 for family living less $11 govt pmts
  • Divided by yield of 29 bushels per acre
  • Equals $5.00 per bushel